This week an important policy debate took place in the Dutch Senate with the Minister of the Interior and Kingdom Relations Piet Hein Donner (of the Christian-democratic party CDA) and the State Secretary for Security and Justice Fred Teeven (of the liberal party VVD) about ‘the role of the government in digital data processing’. In the week following up to the debate Privacy First had expressed its views to the Senate. We are pleased to see that many of our views have been accepted (and even literally copied by some parties) throughout the Senate and that even government members Donner and Teeven proved not to be insensitive to them. This goes for both classic rights and principles that need to be reconfirmed as well as some new starting points:
- the right to express, prior and fully informed consent of citizens in the use of their personal data, both by the government and corporations;
- strict purpose limitation and necessity when using personal data;
- the right of citizens to access, correction and deletion of their personal data;
- privacy, freedom of choice, transparency and effectiveness as leading principles in the drafting of new legislation;
- the importance of evaluation and sunset clauses in (new) legislation;
- public cost-benefit analyses;
- public disclosure of departmental feasibility studies, pilot projects and research reports;
- introduction of privacy impact assessments (PIAs) and privacy by design;
- support of the legislative process by means of expert meetings and external advice.
However, the statement by minister Donner that destroying the fingerprints which are stored by Dutch municipalities would still take months is a great disappointment. The same goes for the fact that there is still no ‘fingerprint-free’ ID card; this too could have been implemented a long time ago. Recently Privacy First urged the minister to execute this process as quickly as possible (be it through modifying relevant legislation or through technical modifications).
A draft report of the Parliamentary debate can be found HERE. Our own audio recordings of the debate can be downloaded HERE. A great number of interesting passages from the debate (both by Members of Parliament as well as members of the government) can be found HERE (in Dutch).